Norman Mailer visits the Dragonfly Inn and is testing Sookie's patience. Rory does research on the Life and Death Brigade for the Yale Daily News, which leads her right back to Logan Huntzberger.
Everyone at the Yale Daily News spent their summers doing internships and being published in The New York Times and Rory panics in fear she hasn’t done enough for her career. Logan Huntzberger arrives after the assignments have been handed out and when Rory asks Doyle why he is letting Logan get away with not doing anything, Doyle informs her it’s because Logan is the son of Mitchum Huntzberger, the newspaper magnate. Rory is thrilled to have the features beat and decides to write about illegal music downloading. While trying to conduct a ground breaking interview with a fellow Yale student, she realizes it’s a dead end. While in the bathroom a girl walks in wearing a gorilla mask and a ball gown. Rory follows her outside, where the girl shouts in Latin before getting into a black SUV. Rory does some research and finds out the Latin phrase is the motto for a secret society at Yale called the Life and Death Brigade. Doyle tells her that everybody knows the society exists, but nobody knows that it does. Rory decides to change her article to undercover the truth about the club and in the course of late night research she discovers that Logan’s grandfather was in the society. Assuming that membership follows family lineage, Rory questions Logan about the Life and Death Brigade. He denies any knowledge, but instant messages her the next day in the newspaper office to tell her he can get her on the inside to write her article.
Back in Stars Hollow, Lorelai receives a desperate phone call from Christopher. Gigi won’t stop crying, Sherry isn’t home and he doesn’t know what to do. Lorelai races to Boston to help out and after getting Gigi quiet Chris says Sherry took a job in Paris, leaving him with their daughter. He thinks he can’t raise her alone, but Lorelai says he can and he will because he has to. Norman Mailer is at the Dragonfly Inn and is annoying Sookie because he sits for hours without ordering anything but iced tea. Sookie becomes more irritated when the Dragonfly’s financial adviser suggests they drop lunch because it’s not making any money. Lorelai can't figure out what's up with Sookie. The girls arrive for Friday night dinner and the maid says Richard is out of town and Emily is at a function. Lorelai decides they should order pizza and eat it on the floor in the living room. After getting comfy Lorelai tells Rory about Christopher and says she plans to go back and help him with Gigi. Rory goes to Christopher’s a few days later and tells him she doesn’t want him to call Lorelai anymore because she’s in a relationship now and she doesn’t want him to mess it up. Lorelai finally has to confront Sookie when Luke calls, upset, because Kirk is in front of the diner handing out flyers to promote lunch at the Dragonfly. Sookie goes into the dining room and yells at Norman Mailer, telling him it’s all his fault. Lorelai drags her away and Sookie says she doesn’t know why she’s freaking out. Suddenly, she realizes she’s pregnant. She runs back out to the dining room and tells Norman Mailer in excitement. At the end of the episode Lorelai goes to the diner and asks Luke why he’s crabby. He nods to a table and complains that a couple of guys are sitting for hours and only ordering iced tea.
- Lauren Graham as Lorelai Gilmore
- Alexis Bledel as Rory Gilmore
- Melissa McCarthy as Sookie St. James
- Yanic Truesdale as Michel Gerard
- Scott Patterson as Luke Danes
- Liza Weil as Paris Geller
- Sean Gunn as Kirk Gleason
Special Guest Stars
- Jared Padalecki as Dean Forester
- David Sutcliffe as Christopher Hayden
- Matt Czuchry as Logan Huntzberger
- Danny Strong as Doyle McMaster
- Ethan Cohn as Glenn Babble
- Rebecca Metz as Ann
- Katherine Bailess as Stephanie
- Alex Weed as Len
- Sherry has left Gigi and Chris, to go to work and live in Paris.
- Sookie is revealed to be pregnant with her second child.
- Glenn gets published in the New York Times, making both Rory and Doyle insecure.
- Rabbi Barans is mentioned as one of the religious leaders Paris has annoyed—although unlikely to be the Stars Hollow rabbi, they do share the same name.
- "Manic Monday" by The Bangles
- Also referenced: Metallica, Tammy Wynette, Interpol, Nick Cave, The Cure, Chicago, ABBA, Frank Zappa, Guns N' Roses, Paul Weller
- The Naked and the Dead by Norman Mailer
- The Armies of the Night: History as a Novel, the Novel as a History; The Executioner's Song by Norman Mailer
- The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time by Mark Haddon
- Gore Vidal
- Gabriel García Marquez
- Paris – We could end up like the Van Burens
- Rory – As in Mr. and Mrs. President?
- Paris – As in Abby and Ann.
- Doyle – It is amazing. It’s absolutely amazing that I spent all summer in Indiana working my ass off for The Muncie Messenger, and you went from Star Trek Convention to Boba Fett Fan Club Symposium, and yet, lookie here. The New York Times. Isn’t that great, Rory? Aren’t you seeing how great it is?
- Glenn – Whatever. Oh man, it’s R.W. Apple again. God, does he have anyone else to talk to?
- Doyle – Oh. That’s a great way to look at it. Thank you! You know, it’s because of me that he’s going to be Bob Woodward
- Rory – I already have a ton of data and pages of research and, oh, the best thing is, Nancy, this girl on the fourth floor, her father was the guy who ran security at the gallery when Lars Ulrich sold all his art and he said he would try to get him on the phone for an interview and I've gotta breathe now
- Rory – Well it was nice knowing you.
- Dean – Way to Stand By Your Man
- Paris – Okay. I'll be back late. If Rabbi Feldman calls, tell him I got the stats from Edward James Olmos' office, so I'm good. Bye.
- Sookie – This is all Norman Mailer’s fault. He just sits around, ordering nothing and yammering on and on and on. I mean, so he was married to Marilyn Monroe. Who wasn’t?
- Lorelai – That was Arthur Miller
- Lorelai – How long ago did Axl Rose leave?
- Lorelai – Yeah, until her hair grows long enough for the prince to shimmy up
- Christopher – No, you’re different, I mean, you’re special. You’re stronger. You’re like a superhero with red boots and a golden lasso
- Rory – It’s sort of a secret society kind of Skull and Bones kind of creepy group dating back to the 1800's